We’ve already checked out how you can build a Mallory or Merit Halloween costume.
But what about Catcher or Jeff? Here are some ideas:
Catcher: T-Shirt | Lifetime Movie DVD | Foam Muscle Costume | Quadrant-esque Temporary Tattoo (It was the closest one I could find!)
Jeff: Khakis | Button down shirt | Achievement Unlocked T-Shirt | Wig | Cthulu Plush